Toronto Metropolitan University
Treating Embryos as Property.pdf (687.16 kB)

Relationally Speaking: The Implications of Treating Embryos as Property in a Canadian Context

Download (687.16 kB)
journal contribution
posted on 2023-03-07, 15:39 authored by Kathleen HammondKathleen Hammond

In July 2018, the Ontario Superior Court, in S.H. v D.H., dealt with a dispute between a recently separated couple over a frozen embryo that the couple had created. In his judgment, Justice Del Frate stated that the embryo should be conceived of as property. This was the cause of uproar among feminist legal scholars who were concerned with the possible repercussions for cisgender women of labeling embryos as property. The Superior Court decision was subsequently overturned by the Ontario Court of Appeal this past May (2019). However, given the likelihood that embryos will be treated as property in future disputes, it is important to assess what the ramifications of this type of categorization might be.